Is a retailer or finance company legally allowed to demand Dealer Subvention (DBD) in cash from a customer under consumer finance?
Jul 25, 2026
107 views
0 answers
Banking Law
► Dear Legal Experts,
I recently purchased a mobile phone at a retail store ("The Chennai Mobiles") financed through a Consumer Sales Loan from HDB Financial Services (HDBFS). At the time of purchase, the store counter demanded and collected ₹15,000 in cash from me.
However, upon reviewing the official Delivery Order and signed Terms & Conditions, I discovered the following discrepancies:
Delivery Order Limit (Line E): The maximum authorized customer collection amount (covering 5 Advance EMIs of ₹13,335 + Processing Fee ₹399 + Convenience Fee ₹499) is ₹14,233.00.
Dealer Bearer Discount (DBD): Item 3 on the Delivery Order lists a Dealer Subvention / DBD charge of ₹708.00, which HDB explicitly excluded from Line E (Customer Collection Limit).
Contract Clause 12.4: The signed Terms & Conditions explicitly state under Clause 12.4 that subvention/DBD fees are payable "by the Relevant Merchant to HDBFS", not by the borrower.
Mobile App Record: HDB’s customer app logs the DBD fee as "RECEIVABLE FROM DEALER".
Despite this, the store counter forcibly collected ₹15,000 in cash (an unauthorized cash overcharge of $\text{₹15,000} - \text{₹14,233} = \text{₹767}$).
Furthermore, RBI Circular DBOD.No.Dir.BC.32/13.03.00/2013-14 strictly prohibits passing merchant subvention or discount charges (DBD) onto zero-percent EMI consumers in cash or hidden costs.
My Questions for the Experts:
Does collecting merchant subvention (DBD) in cash directly from the consumer constitute an Unfair Trade Practice under Section 2(47) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019?
What is the legal liability of the finance company (HDBFS) when its partner retail store overcollects cash beyond the authorized Delivery Order limit?
What are the recommended legal steps if the financier and merchant refuse to refund the ₹767 cash overcharge (e.g., Banking Ombudsman / Consumer Protection Forum)?
107 views
0 answers
0 Answers
No answers yet. Be the first to answer this question!
Log in as a legal professional to answer this question.